The main reason I decided against Butrageuno in the end was that I just know there will be a striker I want more in Season 2. I'm happy to wait for an Henry or someone like that.
I do really like Keane so far, and I am having no issues playing him alongside De Jong, although there is a small part of me that does think what might have been with Zanetti. That's probably just always gonna happen, though. The thing is, though, you can't get Politano to 10 chem with Zanetti without making half of your team Serie A for the entirety of FIFA and I didn't wanna force my hand. And with the already brilliant Politano getting upgraded at some point I don't think he's going to leave my team. Plus I could always buy Zambrotta, or EA might release a flashback Florenzi like they always seem to.
I'd describe Keane as Vidal, on steroids, with insane passing. The passing is incredibly noticeable. The other great thing is that I can switch to 4-1-2-1-2 anytime and he does a great job on his own as a sole CDM.
All that said, I don't think you'd be disappointed with any of Rio, Zanetti or Keane.
I'm gonna get Nesta as well as Keane. I tried Sule and had no issues with his agility so he should fit in nicely for at least a while.